
Reputation and Reviews for Orthopaedic Surgeons
We don't just build websites.
We build positions.
Reviews for orthopaedic surgeons tend to arrive at the wrong time: unhappy patients post during the hard weeks after surgery, while delighted ones forget once they are back on the tennis court. A good review program fixes the timing by asking every patient at a set point in recovery, keeps replies free of any patient detail, and makes sure reviews land on a profile in the surgeon's own name.
Why Timing Matters in Orthopaedics
Recovery is a curve. Two weeks after a knee replacement, a patient is stiff, sore and frustrated with physical therapy. Four months later, the same patient is walking without a cane and grateful. If you only hear from people who post on their own, you mostly hear from the first group.
Ask every patient at a consistent milestone, such as the visit where you clear them for full activity. That is fair under Google's policy, which forbids asking only satisfied patients, and it captures the outcome rather than the hardest week.
What Orthopaedic Reviews Should Say
- The Procedure. A review that says “ACL reconstruction” or “anterior hip replacement” helps the next patient searching for exactly that, and gives AI tools something specific to repeat.
- The Outcome. Back to running, sleeping through the night, playing with grandchildren. Patients look for outcomes like their own goals.
- The Team. Physician assistants, surgery schedulers and therapists shape the experience. Reviews that mention them reflect real care.
Replying Without Revealing
A patient may post that their shoulder still hurts and name the date of surgery. You still cannot discuss it. HHS has settled with practices that replied to reviews with treatment details; in 2019 a Dallas dental practice paid $10,000 for exactly that. Thank the reviewer, say you take every concern seriously, and invite a call to the office. Then actually call.
Whose Name Are the Reviews On?
In large orthopaedic groups, reviews often land on a location profile shared by twenty surgeons. Your own patients' praise then builds the group's rating, not yours. Google's guidelines allow a practitioner who sees patients directly to have a separate profile. Combined with a personal website in your own name, it means the reputation you earn follows you to your next group or your own practice.
Rules That Apply to Everyone
- No Incentives. No gift cards or drawings for reviews. Google bans them, and the FTC bans incentives tied to positive or negative sentiment.
- No Insider Reviews. Staff and relatives should not review the practice. If they do, the FTC requires the connection to be disclosed.
- Testimonials on Your Site. Patient stories are advertising once you publish them. Do not present an elite athlete's return to play as the typical result.
Is your market still open?
We work with one doctor per specialty, per city. Find out if yours is open. Search a few of these with your city. If your name is not on the first screen, your patients are finding someone else.
Get My Free AI Check arrow_forwardOur playbook stays private.
We know what moves a doctor to the top of the list in their city, and we have the tools to do it. We don't publish how, because that work belongs to our clients, and we never hand it to their competition.
Ask for your free AI Check. You see exactly where you stand in your city, and we show you, privately, what we would do about it.
Need a website now? Start here.
It takes 20 seconds. Tell us who you are and what you need, and we will reach you within one business day.

Reputation and Reviews for Orthopaedic Surgeons FAQs.
When should we ask surgical patients for a review?
At a consistent recovery milestone for every patient, such as the visit where they are cleared for activity. Asking everyone at that point is fair and captures real outcomes.
Can I respond to a patient who blames me for a complication?
Publicly, only in general terms with no patient details. Offer a private conversation. Discussing the case online can violate HIPAA.
Do reviews on the hospital's site count?
They help patients who find them, but you rarely control them. Reviews on your own Google profile and a site in your name are the ones you keep.
Can our physical therapists ask for reviews too?
Yes, as long as they ask every patient, not only happy ones, and offer nothing in return.
SEO for Orthopaedic Surgeons · AI Search Visibility for Orthopaedic Surgeons · How Much Does an Orthopaedic Surgeon Website Cost?
Website Design for Orthopaedic Surgeons · Medical Website Design · Free AI Check
Sources
- Google Maps User Contributed Content Policy: Prohibited and Restricted Content (no incentives, no selectively soliciting positive reviews, no conflicts of interest)
- Google Business Profile Help, Guidelines for Representing Your Business on Google (individual practitioners may have their own profile)
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Dental Practice Pays $10,000 to Settle Social Media Disclosures of Patients' Protected Health Information, October 2, 2019
- Federal Trade Commission, Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials, August 14, 2024 (16 CFR Part 465)
- Federal Trade Commission, FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking